Grand Theft Auto IV (GTA 4) is renowned for its engaging narrative and morally ambiguous choices that players must make throughout the game. Unlike previous entries, GTA 4 presents a series of decisions that influence character relationships, mission outcomes, and even the ending of the game. Some choices, however, are particularly detrimental, leading to severe consequences for protagonist Niko Bellic and his allies. This article delves into some of the worst choices a player can make in GTA 4 and their lasting impacts on the storyline.
Blood Brothers: Choosing Between Francis and Derrick McReary
One of the most difficult choices in GTA 4 comes in the mission “Blood Brothers,” where Niko must decide whether to kill Francis or Derrick McReary. While neither character is particularly noble, killing Derrick is generally the worse option, as it results in losing any potential favors from Francis, such as calling off police pursuits. Additionally, Derrick’s death leads to a negative reaction from his family, including Packie McReary, who is one of Niko’s closest allies.
Uncle Vlad: The Impulsive Murder
Niko’s decision to kill Vlad Glebov is an example of a choice that is inevitable but still carries massive consequences. Vlad was a small-time criminal, but he was connected to powerful Russian figures. His death sets off a chain reaction that brings Niko and Roman into conflict with more dangerous adversaries, ultimately escalating into the main conflict with Dimitri Rascalov and the Russian mafia.
Final Destination: Following Orders Blindly
In the mission “Final Destination,” Niko is ordered to kill Lenny Petrovic, the son of a powerful Russian gangster. Following through with this order turns out to be a terrible decision, as it provokes the wrath of the Petrovic family. This escalates the conflict significantly and results in Dimitri using Niko to further his own agenda, ultimately betraying him.
The Holland Play: Killing Dwayne or Playboy X
Players are given the choice to kill either Dwayne Forge or Playboy X. The worst choice here is to kill Dwayne. While Playboy X offers money in return, he ultimately abandons Niko and cuts all ties. Killing Playboy X, on the other hand, grants Niko a luxurious penthouse and a valuable friendship with Dwayne, who provides backup in future missions.
The Deal with Dimitri: A Fatal Mistake
Towards the end of the game, players must decide whether to accept a deal with Dimitri Rascalov or seek revenge. Choosing to work with Dimitri results in Roman’s tragic death, a devastating consequence that significantly impacts Niko’s journey. This choice also leads to increased conflict and betrayal, making it one of the worst decisions a player can make.
Conclusion
GTA 4 presents players with a range of moral dilemmas, and while some choices appear ambiguous, others clearly lead to worse outcomes. Understanding the consequences of these decisions can help players navigate Niko Bellic’s journey more effectively. Making informed choices enhances the experience, ensuring a more rewarding and immersive playthrough.
